What Are Unlicensed Online Casinos?
From a UK perspective, overseas unlicensed online casinos are gambling sites based outside of the UK that operate without regulation from the UK Gambling Commission (UKGC). These casinos are often licensed in other jurisdictions like Malta, Curacao, or Gibraltar and are not bound by UK laws.
Overseas unlicensed casinos operate to bypass the strict rules and taxes imposed by the UKGC, allowing them to offer different bonuses, games, and payment options. Some UK players are drawn to these sites as they can bypass self-exclusion tools like GAMSTOP, though these platforms come with significant risks, including lack of player protection and data security concerns.
Taxation on Legal UK Operators
Licensed UK online casinos must pay a 15% Remote Gaming Duty on profits from UK-based players, regardless of where the casino’s operations are located. Even if a casino is based overseas, as long as it is licensed by the UKGC and offers services to UK players, it is subject to this tax. This ensures that the UK benefits from tax revenues on gambling activities, even when the companies are based abroad, helping regulate and control the industry within UK laws.
Taxation at Unlicensed Online Casinos
Unlicensed online casinos often pay taxes in the jurisdictions where they are licensed. However, the tax rates in these locations are typically lower than the 15% Remote Gaming Duty imposed by the UK.
For example, Curacao has a much lower tax rate of around 2% on profits, which makes these jurisdictions attractive to operators looking to minimise their tax liabilities. While they do contribute to local taxes, the rates are often far less than what they would pay under UK regulations.
Official Confirms Unlicensed Winning are Tax-Free
According to an official statement on the HMRC tax forum, the UK government does not collect taxes on winnings from unlicensed overseas online casinos. Even though these casinos operate outside UK regulation, players’ winnings remain untaxed under current UK law.
An HMRC official confirmed that “gambling winnings, whether from licensed or unlicensed casinos, are not taxable in the UK.” This includes winnings from overseas sites that are not regulated by the UK Gambling Commission.
How Much is the UK Government Potentially Losing Out?
According to estimates, UK players place around £4.3 billion in bets at unlicensed casinos annually. Assuming a low 90% Return to Player (RTP), approximately £3.87 billion is returned to players in winnings.
If these winnings were taxed under the 24% Capital Gains Tax rate, that would generate £928 million in potential tax revenue. Currently, these funds remain untaxed, representing a substantial loss to the UK Treasury.
How the UK Could Tax Winnings from Unlicensed Online Casinos
The UK could tax players’ winnings from unlicensed online casinos in three ways. One approach is to tax net profits, where players are taxed on their total winnings minus losses. Another method is taxing based on trade volume, where taxes apply to every transaction, similar to taxing financial trades. Lastly, Capital Gains Tax could be imposed on all winnings.
Taxing Player Profits
Taxing profits from unlicensed casinos would involve taxing net gains—total winnings minus losses. Implementing this would face significant logistical challenges, as it requires precise tracking of all transactions on unregulated platforms, many of which are located overseas. This would demand substantial resources to verify and monitor.
Taxing Trade Volume
Taxing trade volumes would involve levying a tax on each transaction made at unlicensed casinos, regardless of the outcome. This approach could generate significant revenue, as it taxes all player activity. However, implementing this system would be complicated due to the scale of transactions and foreign jurisdictions.
Taxing Winnings Using Capital Gains Tax
Another approach could be to tax all winnings from unlicensed casinos using Capital Gains Tax. This would involve treating any winnings from these platforms as capital gains, taxing them at the standard rate. While simpler than tracking net profits or trade volume, it still faces logistical challenges, such as ensuring players report their winnings and enforcing compliance on unregulated, overseas platforms.
The Risks of Unlicensed Overseas Casinos for Players and the UK Government
Unlicensed overseas casinos pose significant risks to players and the UK government. These sites operate without regulation, meaning no guarantees of fair play or secure transactions. Players risk their funds and data without the safeguards found on licensed UK platforms. Additionally, the government loses out on potential tax revenue, as players who gamble on unlicensed sites could otherwise play on regulated platforms that contribute to the economy.
Beyond revenue loss, unlicensed casinos often bypass responsible gambling measures. They don’t offer tools like GAMSTOP, which helps vulnerable players manage their habits, increasing the risks for those prone to problem gambling.
Licensed UK casinos must adhere to strict UKGC regulations to promote player safety, which many overseas sites ignore. Players can check the list of all UKGC licensed casinos to make sure they’re gambling on secure and regulated platforms that prioritise fairness and protection.
Another issue is transparency. Unlicensed casinos frequently operate with vague or deceptive terms, offering bonuses and promotions with unreasonable wagering requirements or hidden fees. However, UK-licensed sites must disclose terms, ensuring fair play for all players.
Finally, taxing winnings from unlicensed sites could act as a deterrent, making these platforms less attractive to players. By implementing such a tax, the government could encourage players to stay within the regulated market, reducing the appeal of unlicensed sites and bolstering tax revenue from the legal gambling sector.
Measures to Reduce UK Players Using Unlicensed Casinos Without Taxation
- Affiliate Takedowns: The government could work with search engines like Google to remove or demote affiliate websites promoting unlicensed casinos, reducing their visibility to UK players.
- DNS Blocking: Requiring ISPs to block access to unlicensed sites, similar to measures taken in other countries, would prevent players from easily accessing these platforms.
- Payment Blocking: Strengthen collaborations with banks and payment processors to block transactions to unlicensed casinos.
- Public Awareness Campaigns: Launch larger campaigns educating players on the risks of using unlicensed sites, focusing on security and player protection issues.
- Stronger Self-Exclusion: Expand tools like GAMSTOP to block access to unlicensed casinos, and incorporate services like Gamban, which attempts to block all gambling sites worldwide, further reducing the ability for vulnerable players to access such platforms.
Conclusion: Is Taxation Worth the Bother?
Taxing players at unlicensed online casinos would be a difficult and largely untested approach. No country has successfully implemented a model for tracking and taxing individuals on these unregulated platforms. Countries like Norway and Italy have tried to restrict access through payment blocking but not through meaningful taxation of players themselves.
The logistical challenges of enforcing such a tax—tracking offshore transactions and ensuring compliance—would require vast resources and cooperation with foreign jurisdictions. Without a global precedent, it remains a complex solution, and exploring alternative methods like blocking access to these sites or public awareness campaigns might be more effective in reducing participation.